Well, there are more than just one commonly used cabin décor materials, but the most encountered are wood and stone, which are destined to help the owners create the impression of a rustic environment.
You might consider commissioning an auction to sell the furnishings. If the cabin décor is authentic many collectors may be interested in paying good money for the furnishings you are will to sell.
There are those dealers who specialize in western style cabin décor and can accommodate just about any budget. Depending on how much money you are willing to spend you could locate a dealer online and select from many products available. The dealer would ship the items directly to the cabin or you could pick them up and save a little money.
Obviously your husband likes to surround himself with the trappings of a hunter’s lifestyle. Maybe you could suggest to him that you pick a few places where the two of you could vacation. This would give you the opportunity to balance his preferences with yours. Pick a location that can satisfy both of your needs. With you selecting a spot you can show him what you like and perhaps next time he will take your likes into consideration when planning the trip.